KPRJ, KP Research Journal, KPJA

Peer Review Policy

The review process ensures that every manuscript is evaluated rigorously, fairly and according to the criteria in this Policy. All research articles, case commentaries, book reviews and legislative reviews are subject to double-blind peer review through OJS. The identities of authors and reviewers will be concealed from each other throughout.

  1. Screening. The Managing Editor shall check scope, completeness of files, format and OSCOLA compliance, anonymization, the similarity report and the AI declaration, within 14 working days. Non-compliant manuscripts will be returned once for correction, within 7 days, and if not rectified, these will be rejected.
  2. Editorial assessment. The Editor-in-Chief or Editor will decide to reject at this stage or send the manuscript for review, with in a fortnight.
  3. Double-blind review. At least two independent reviewers assess each manuscript, at least one of whom is external to KPJA. Reviewers must hold a PhD or recognized expertise in the field, be free from conflict, and return the report within 21–30 days. A third reviewer is appointed if the first two disagree materially. Reviewers shall treat manuscripts as confidential. They will not copy or share them, and report any suspected plagiarism, fabrication or ethical concern. An author who disagrees with a decision may request reconsideration on procedural or factual grounds within 15 days. The request shall be decided by the Editor-in-Chief together with an Associate Editor who was not involved in the original decision.
  4. Criteria. The criteria for review include but not limited to, originality and contribution; quality of legal analysis and reasoning; soundness of method; relevance to the administration of justice; accuracy and completeness of authorities; clarity of expression; compliance with research ethics and this Policy. (Detailed Guidance is Annex-A, below). 
  5. Decision. The Editor-in-Chief shall decide to accept, accept with minor revisions, require major revisions with re-review, or reject, normally within 45 days of submission, and shall communicate the decision and the anonymized reports to the author.
  6. Revision. Authors shall submit the revised manuscript and a point-by-point response within 14 days (minor) or 30 days (major).
  7. Post-acceptance. Similarity and AI checks will be repeated on the final text, followed by proofs reading and publication on the Journal website within 75 days of acceptance.

 

Annex A: Reviewer Evaluation Guidelines

(to be read with Part 12 of the Policy)

1. Purpose and Application

1.1 These Guidelines help reviewers assess manuscripts consistently, fairly and constructively. They supplement Part 12 of the Policy and do not replace it.

1.2 They apply to every reviewer of research articles, case commentaries, legislative reviews and book reviews. Reviewers accept an invitation on the understanding that they will follow them.

2. Principles of Review

A reviewer shall:

  • Be impartial. Judge the manuscript on its quality, not on whether it supports a theory, school of thought or outcome the reviewer prefers. A reviewer who cannot separate evaluation from advocacy must decline or recuse.
  • Be constructive and courteous. Criticize the work, never the author. For instance, consider writing "substantial concerns" or "major issues" rather than "fatal flaws" or "serious mistakes".
  • Be specific. Identify the page, section or footnote concerned and say how it can be improved, so that the author can understand and act on the comment.
  • Be balanced. Record strengths as well as weaknesses, in enough detail to support the recommendation.
  • Be accurate. Give a full citation whenever referring to other work.
  • Be timely. Return the report within the period in Part 12 (21–30 days), and inform the Editor early if more time is needed.

3. Before Accepting a Review

3.1 Competence. Accept only if you have recognized expertise in the field. If you can assess only part of the manuscript, say so in your confidential note to the Editor.

3.2 Conflict of interest. Decline if you have a personal, financial, professional or institutional conflict with the author, or cannot be impartial.

3.3 Suspected identity. Knowing or suspecting the author's identity, for example from an earlier presentation, does not by itself disqualify a reviewer. Inform the Editor promptly and let the Editor decide.

4. Confidentiality and Anonymity

4.1 The manuscript is confidential. Do not copy it, share it, or discuss it with anyone, including colleagues and students, without the Editor's permission.

4.2 Do not reveal your identity in the report, in comments to the author or in the file properties of any document you upload. Do not try to identify the author.

4.3 Do not use the manuscript for your own research or writing.

5. Artificial Intelligence

5.1 Reviewers must not use AI tools to evaluate a manuscript or draft the report, and must not upload any part of a manuscript into a public AI tool.

5.2 Reviewers receive only the anonymized final manuscript. If you suspect undisclosed AI use, fabricated or unverifiable citations, or invented quotations, report it in the confidential note to the Editor with the specific passages. Do not accuse the author, in the comments to the author.

6. Evaluation Criteria

Assess each manuscript against the criteria below, which expand Part 12(iv). Rate each criterion using this scale:

  • S = Strong
  • A = Acceptable
  • I = Needs improvement
  • U = Unsatisfactory
  • N/A = Not applicable

No.

Criterion

Guiding questions

Rating

1.       

Title

Does the title accurately reflect the aims and conclusions?

 

2.       

Abstract

Does the abstract (200–300 words) summarize the argument, method and findings?

 

3.       

Originality and contribution

Does the work add something new to scholarship or practice, or merely restate the existing law?

 

4.       

Relevance

Is it relevant to law and the administration of justice, in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan or comparatively?

 

5.       

Aims

Are the aims clear and does the research address them?

 

6.       

Structure

Are the sections logically arranged, of suitable length and concise? Is the word count within the limit for the category?

 

7.       

Legal analysis and reasoning

Is the argument coherent and supported by authority? Are counter-arguments considered? Do the conclusions and any recommendations follow from the analysis?

 

8.       

Accuracy and completeness of authorities

Are the key cases, statutes and secondary sources cited, current and correctly stated? Do any citations appear unverifiable or invented?

 

9.       

Soundness of method

Is the doctrinal, empirical, comparative or interdisciplinary method appropriate and clearly explained?

 

10.   

Quality and depth of scholarship

Does the author engage with the relevant literature and case law in depth, rather than superficially?

 

11.   

Footnotes and OSCOLA

Are footnotes relevant and consistently in OSCOLA (5th edition)? Are Pakistani authorities cited in home-jurisdiction form?

 

12.   

Tables and figures

Are they relevant, accurate and properly captioned and sourced?

 

13.   

Language and style

Is the writing clear, precise and professional, with accurate grammar? Is gender-neutral language used?

 

14.   

Research ethics and policy compliance

Is the work free from suspected plagiarism, fabrication or undisclosed AI use? If it discusses a case, does it avoid pending matters and confidential judicial information? Is personal data anonymized?

 

7. Notes by Category

  • Research Article (4,000–6,000 words). Assess the research question, method, depth of analysis and the originality of the argument.
  • Case Commentary / Case Note (1,000–2,000 words). Does it state the facts, issues, holding and reasoning accurately, and go beyond summary to a critical analysis of the reasoning and its effect on law and practice?
  • Legislative Review (1,000–2,000 words). Does it explain the provisions and their context, identify gaps or conflicts, compare other approaches where useful, and make practical recommendations?
  • Book Review (1,500–3,000 words). Does it summarize the book fairly, evaluate its arguments and contribution critically, and avoid being merely descriptive?

8. Writing the Report


A report should contain:
1. Summary. A short statement of what the manuscript argues and what you understand its contribution to be.
2. Strengths. What the manuscript does well.
3. Major issues. Substantial concerns affecting the argument, method, accuracy of authorities or originality, with page or section references.
4. Minor issues. Points of detail, such as citation, language, structure or formatting.
5. Suggestions. Specific, practical steps for improvement.
6. Recommendation. One of the four options in section 9, below.
7. Confidential note to the Editor (not sent to the author). Include any concern about competence to assess part of the manuscript, suspected identity, suspected plagiarism, fabrication or undisclosed AI use, or other ethical concerns, with the reasons.


Comments to the author must be courteous, must not identify the reviewer, and must be consistent with the recommendation.

 

9. Recommendations

The reviewer recommendation may be in the following categories.

Recommendation

Meaning

Author's revision period

Accept

Publishable as submitted, apart from editorial copy-editing.

Not applicable

Accept with minor revisions

Sound work needing limited corrections, which the Editor can check without further review.

14 days

Major revisions with re-review

Promising work with substantial weaknesses. The revised version must be reviewed again.

30 days

Reject

Fundamental flaws in originality, method, accuracy or ethics that revision cannot reasonably cure, or the manuscript is outside the Journal's scope.

Not applicable

10. Misconduct and Concerns

10.1 A reviewer who suspects plagiarism, fabrication, undisclosed AI use, duplicate submission or another ethical breach must report it to the Editor in the confidential note and not investigate it independently. The Editor will deal with the matter under Part 14 of the Policy.

10.2 A reviewer must not use a manuscript's contents, ideas or data before publication, and must not contact the author directly.

10.3 Failure to follow these Guidelines, including breach of confidentiality, may lead to removal from the reviewer pool.

11. Re-review of Revised Manuscripts

11.1 Where a manuscript is revised, the reviewer checks whether the author has addressed each major issue in the point-by-point response, and recommends accordingly.

11.2 A reviewer who finds a revision has introduced new material or concerns should state this in the report and the confidential note.

12. Acknowledgement

Reviewers' contributions are valued and recorded by the Journal. Reviewers' identities are never disclosed to authors. KPJA may issue a certificate of reviewing on request.

Reviewer declaration (to be completed on OJS with each report):

I confirm that I have no conflict of interest in this review, have not used AI tools to evaluate the manuscript or write this report, have kept the manuscript confidential, and have followed these Guidelines.